Search for a new job

Find Jobs

 
Home > Careers & Employment > Other > Is the movie The Devil Wears Prada a great job-training movie for people fresh out of college?

Is the movie The Devil Wears Prada a great job-training movie for people fresh out of college?

Category: Other

SwimmerSwimmer


I'm 28 years old, and I can safely say I have accomplished more than most of my college friends. My first boss at my very first job was as bad a Miranda Priestly from the movie The Devil WeaBIOSPrada. My boss was just like her, she treated her subordinates in a manner that borders on emotional and psychological abuse.

During my first job after college, I worked like I've never worked in my life. My boss made me do so many things that were not part of my job description. She was a merciless, cruel woman, making the experience of being her assistant a living hell. I sacrificed my personal life for a year, but I was able to keep up with her unrealistic expectations just like Andrea Sachs did. Eventually I quit after one long difficult year.

However, I gained a lot from working for her. I learned the real meaning of working hard and going the extra mile for your job. While most of my college friends would complain about the most insignificant things about their jobs, I learned what it meant to make sacrifices for your job.

Today, I'm 28 years old, and I'm doing better than every one of my college friends. Ever since working for my first boss, I have not worked as hard. But I have worked harder than what's expected of me, and that's what got me ahead.

Today, I'm grateful for having my first boss being such a sociopath. I've had problems at my job and with my boss from time to time, but nothing ever compares to the problems I had during my first job, so for that I am grateful.

A lot of college students and college graduates need to understand that they need to do enormous efforts to excel in their jobs.

Should the movie The Devil Wears Prada be used for job-training?

cainvest1
cainvest1

What your first boss taught you was to stand up for yourself. But there is no need to put up with abuse at work and I wouldn't put this movie at the top of my training list.

FWIW your generation has an off-putting sense of entitlement that you have learned won't get you far in the business world. You learned the hard way the value of going above and beyond instead of whining about how hard things are.

I wish your first boss would have been a better manager. There is no need to learn things this way. But you often learn valuable lessons from those that are the most demanding. It sounds like you listened, and then acted in your own interest to improve your situation. Good for you!!

tentoes
tentoes

No, it should not. The only thing that you can really get out of that movie is to never let a job compromise who you are.

Nick
Nick

It should be used a film to show students what a job SHOULDN'T be like. If you have a job like that quit....and/or sue the boss.

Daniel
Daniel

People react differently to different things. While its not a good idea to be overly sensitive, It is also important for a boss to be diplomatic and kind. Employee morale is extremely important, and companies know this. Large companies spend millions, sometimes billions of dollars on improving morale. Bonuses, company events, exercise rooms, break rooms with free refreshments, comfortable chairs, health and dental benefits, etc.

If a person in a management position is hurting morale by being unnecessarily harsh or rude, then they are not doing their job, and should be demoted or fired.

Even in grunt jobs, morale is important, as it costs a lot of time, money and resources to train an employee, and an experienced employee will outperform an intermediate employee dramatically, provided they are happy.

While you may have turned out well from this experience, other people may not have.

You might also be biased by nostalgia.

Its human nature to look back on hard times in your life with a positive bias. This is why abused women often go back to their abusive husbands/boyfriends. They don't remember the abuse, just the hugs, and the kisses, and the flowers, and the apologies.

Same thing with people who say "kids these days". They look back and see their childhood as near-perfect, and they focus on the negative of now.

Anyway, to answer your question, no, as if someone who watches it reaches a management position, they might think that such behavior is acceptable.


Share this on your favorite networks

Career Discussions

Feather Teen that needs a summer job!!? (2 answers)

I need a summer job badly got any ideas ...

¥Sansa¥ What do I enter for "job reference" if this is going to be my first job? (4 answers)

I'm apply for a job online, and they require a "job reference." I've never had a job before, so what do I enter? ...

orangeysweet Can my potential employer find this out in a background check? (5 answers)

I was just offered a job by J.C. Penney, and they said the next step would be a background check. I have no criminal history, but on my application, I ...

Chandler Interview for a job in an amusement park? (2 answers)

I have an interview in thorpe park, and they asked me to bring something that represents insane fun to me. I don't know what to bring, any ideas? ...

ZikoD Im majoring in Marketing but i got an offer to work as a receptionist in a good hotel? should i accept or not? (1 answers)

Its not related to my field of study so i feel like it wont give me any kind of experience, what would u do? ...

MappyGoldSchmidt Rewriting policy: How many "chances" should you give an employee before firing them? (2 answers)

Here is a bit of background on a situation to use as a reference point-A particular employee continues to make very obvious mistakes that have been di ...

John Yves For example I'm a CIA agent, why can't I tell to anyone that I'm a CIA agent or a spy.? (5 answers)

Just curious cuz like in Alias, being a CIA agent is a secret to their friends and families... Just wondering why they can't tell it to anyone, a ...

Peace, Love, Beatles <3 I hate my job but I just got it? (5 answers)

I've been trying to get this job like the entire spring. It's at an ice cream shop, my cousin has worked there for six summers or something ...

Dustin Is mandatory overtime Legal in Colorado? (4 answers)

I recently received an email from my boss telling me that if someone does not come in to relieve me at my work station that i will have to stay over u ...

gigs Will it be considered as unethical ?? What would you do in this situation? (1 answers)

I am working for a company "A" and they deputed me to a project in another country but via a local recruiting company "B". Legally ...